A dispute over two similarly pronounced brand names has prompted the Bangladesh Telecommunication Regulatory Commission (BTRC) to issue a show-cause notice to Robi Axiata PLC over its use of ‘Cirkle’. The action followed a complaint from an internet service provider that claims to have used the name ‘Circle’ since 2014.
The telecom regulator issued the notice on 26 October, asking Robi to explain within seven days why it should not be directed to stop the activities in question.
The action followed a complaint filed on 8 September by Circle Network proprietor Mahbub Alam, who argued that Robi’s ‘Cirkle’ brand could confuse customers and undermine his company’s established business identity and goodwill.
In its notice, BTRC said Robi was conducting commercial activities under the ‘Cirkle’ brand without prior approval, despite another BTRC-licensed company operating as Circle Network since 2016. The regulator also raised concerns about possible inconsistencies with intellectual property laws.
According to the complaint, Circle Network has used its name since 17 February 2014 in licence-related documents, renewal records, official correspondence, tariff approvals, and business and promotional activities.
The company received a Nationwide Internet Service Provider (ISP) licence from BTRC on 1 March 2016 and has since operated under that name.
Alam argued that ‘Circle’ and ‘Cirkle’, despite their different English spellings, have similar pronunciations and visual characteristics. Both are commonly pronounced as ‘Circle’, potentially leading customers to assume a business relationship, affiliation, partnership or service connection between the companies.
He said different logos and English spellings were insufficient to prevent confusion because the names sound almost identical and have the same Bengali identity.
The concern is particularly relevant, according to the complaint, because both companies operate in the broader telecommunications and internet services sector. Circle Network provides nationwide internet services, while Robi is a nationwide mobile telecommunications operator.
Alam warned that widespread promotion of the Cirkle brand could create an unintended association with Circle Network, damaging its reputation and goodwill built over years of operation.
He urged BTRC to take legal and regulatory measures to stop Robi’s use of the name, citing his company’s prior use, established identity and commercial interests.
However, he clarified that the objection was intended to protect Circle Network’s brand identity, not challenge Robi’s right to operate its telecommunications business.
The BTRC notice also raised a separate issue concerning Airtel’s status following its merger with Robi in 2016.
Under the merger conditions, Robi Axiata Ltd was required to operate under its own corporate name. A directive issued by the Posts and Telecommunications Division on 23 July 2023 also clarified that Airtel was no longer an independently licensed operator but a brand of Robi Axiata Ltd.
BTRC also questioned the presentation of Airtel as an operator in advertisements, noting that it is a Robi brand rather than a separately licensed operator.
The regulator sought Robi’s explanation on both the use of the ‘Cirkle’ brand and Airtel’s representation as an operator.
Robi was contacted for comment on the allegations and asked whether it had responded to BTRC’s show-cause notice. The company had not commented on either matter by the time this report was filed.







